THE STORY
We don’t get off the Monterey Peninsula very often, but we were able to tag a weekend in the Shenandoah Valley area of Amador County onto a rare trip up north. I’m a Zinfandel girl at heart, so it was fun to get back to my wine loving roots. I had never visited the Sierra Foothills wineries, so everything was a first for me. We were able to spend 2 days wine tasting – and I am so glad we did!
The hills were very dry in Shenandoah Valley and the road to get there was narrow and windy. It didn’t look like anyplace I had been before. We are talking rural. We blew right past Plymouth in the blink of an eye. And suddenly we found our first winery! We were able to visit each of the wineries without a reservation (it was mid-November, after all) and were please by the affordability of the tasting fees – in some places there was no tasting fee at all!
We stayed in tiny Plymouth at the lovely boutique Rest hotel (highly recommended) and had our first night’s meal at Taste, a first-rate experience across the board.
This is going to be a two-part series highlighting my recommendations of standout wineries and wines based on our visit. Today’s post focuses on Villa Toscano, Cooper Vineyards and Scott Harvey Wines. I’d like to share with you some of our experiences on our first day visiting. We did not make it to all the wineries recommended to us. I’m going to focus on the highlights to keep this as short and sweet as possible.
THE SIERRA FOOTHILLS WINE REGION
Let’s start at the top with a history of the Sierra Foothills Wine Region from this Wine Enthusiast article:
“The region’s wine industry dates back to the Gold Rush when, in the mid 1800s, hundreds of thousands of people from all over the world arrived searching for riches. Some looked for gold and others, like businessmen Levi Strauss, Domingo Ghirardelli and Henry Wells and William G. Fargo, serviced those looking for gold. Southern European settlers, mainly from Italy, first began planting grapevines in the area. The region’s diverse soils proved ideal for growing grapes. The wine industry soon took off thanks to a population boom and by the early 1900s, the Sierra Foothills had become a major producer for California.
“Unfortunately, Prohibition dealt a severe blow to business. But vineyards were merely abandoned instead of being ripped out entirely. In the 1970s, winemakers began to discover the many old vines still producing high-quality grapes and saw potential in the Sierra Foothills. In 1987, The Sierra Foothills American Viticulture Area (AVA), with its six sub-zones of California Shenandoah Valley, Amador County, El Dorado, Fair Play, Fiddletown and North Yuba, was officially established. Today, the region has more than 200 wineries.”
ABOUT AMADOR COUNTY WINEGROWING REGIONS
We didn’t know much about Amador County wines, so relied on this Amador Vintners website plus recommendations from friends and wine ratings to pick our stops. Our experience spanned some of the oldest wineries in the region to some of the newest. Most of the wineries we visited were in the Shenandoah Valley AVA, known for its Zinfandel and Barbera wines, but it is much more than that. At the recommendation of the hotel’s happy hour winery, we also drove over to Fiddletown to check out a newer winery focusing on Rhône varietals. That will be in next week’s post!
From Amador Vintners: “Amador Wine Country: Relaxed and Unpretentious. With a stunning setting in the Sierra Foothills that delivers an authentic wine country experience. Exactly how you remember California’s wine country used to be. The 50+ wineries comprising the Amador Vintners Association are dedicated to producing premium-quality wines that offer distinctive regional character. This character can also be seen in each winery’s genuine brand of hospitality!”
THE WINERIES & WINES
I have 6 wines to present to you today from Villa Toscano, Cooper Vineyards and Scott Harvey Wines. Winery notes are from their websites, tasting sheets, or conversations with staff. I would like to add an honorable mention to the 2022 Jeff Runquist Tempranillo, $32 (#1496) – My Notes: Beautiful dark color in the glass. Balanced, big bold flavors with cassis on the finish. This was our favorite by far at this winery.
Villa Toscano
Our first stop was Villa Toscano – mostly because it boasted lunch at its Bistro and was a good place to rendezvous with our friends. It’s older architecture in a Tuscan style, reminiscent of times gone by. We got their first and made a bee line to their Tasting Room, where the staff helped us hone in on a few of the best reds. We were pleasantly surprised. It was also the first place we encountered a White Barbera!
There are so many wines to explore here (the image above is only their reds!) and it is worthy of a future visit, when we can spend more than 10 minutes in the tasting room! Here are a couple of the wines we liked so much that we took them home!
2020 Villa Toscano Gold Rush Old Vine Zinfandel, Shenandoah Valley AVA, Amador County, 15.7% ABV, $45 (#1494)
Winery Notes: “Blackberry, mulberry with bold acidity. Notes of leather and black currant.”
My Review: Cinnamon and cherry on the nose. Lingering palate of jammy, dark fruit. That is a mouthful. A Sharon kind of wine. We took a 2019 and a 2020 home. November 2024
2020 Bella Piazza Montepulciano, Shenandoah Valley AVA, Amador County, $38 (#1495)
Winery Notes for the 2019 Vintage: “Dark berry and red plum aromas with subtle notes of violet and dried herbs.”
My Review: I don’t have detailed tasting notes on this wine. The nose had some sweetness to it – in a good way, followed by a velvety palate of bold flavors. We took 2 home. November 2024
Cooper Vineyards
When we walked into Cooper Vineyard’s bustling tasting room, we immediately felt the down-to-earth cowboy vibe. The friendly staff walked us through each wine and several made my list. Alas, I only managed to take one home.
About Cooper Vineyards: “Since the 1970s, the Cooper Family’s mission has been to produce the highest quality fruit and present it to you in exquisite single varietal wines and beautifully balanced blends. Beginning with Barbera, Dick Cooper, family patriarch, carefully tended rolling vineyards that now boast seventeen varietals…Today our premium grapes are producing award-winning wines characterized by rich flavors and lush aromas with subtle fruitiness, balanced tannins, layered complexities, and smooth, lingering finishes.”
2021 Cooper Vineyards Barbera Riserva, Amador County, $47 (#1497)
Winery Notes: “With its perfect marriage of floral and fruity aromas, our 2021 Barbera Riserva wraps itself around you like a big hug. Caramel, apple, leather and cloves on the nose deliver pure joy and pleasure in each and every sip. A subtle spice and heat (could it be red pepper?) merge with a suggestion of raspberry to bring you a finish that is super smooth, dark and rich. A labor of love, this Riserva is barrel select and aged 34 months in 100% New American Oak. Awesome with Drunken Steak with Shitake Mushrooms.”
My Review: Dark fruit/prune and vanilla on the nose. Big dark fruit on the front palate and a lot of sweet on the finish jammy. Good balance of some sweet and tart. Perhaps our favorite Barbera of the day. November 2024
2021 Cooper Vineyards Mourvèdre, Amador County, $32 (#1498)
Winery Notes: Known by many names, Mourvedre is thought to have originated in Spain but is best known as a Rhone varietal. Historically used as a blending grape, Mourvèdre arrived in California in the 1860’s. Our 2021 single varietal Mourvèdre is not for the faint of heart with unique and captivating aromas of toffee and leather, and whispers of sandalwood – earthy, woody, sweet, spicy. This complex wine presents with warm and rich flavors of espresso, oaked vanilla and smokiness. Think stews, braises and other rich and hearty dishes as perfect food pairings.
My Review: Coffee with a hint of smoke on the nose. This wine presents as a classic Mourvèdre. Herbal, dark and brooding and quite tasty. November 2024
Cooper Vineyards Ranch Red, Amador County, 14.5% ABV, $32 (#1499)
Winery Notes: “This innovative blend of Alicante Bouchet (38%), Carignane (25%), Charbono (25%) and Barbera (12%), all 2021 vintages, is rustic yet exotic. Scents of cherry, cola, clove, cinnamon, leather, pepper and sandalwood precede flavors of warm spice, black fruits and the umami characteristics of smoked meat. Soft tannins, balanced acidity and a juicy finish will have you exclaiming…a triumph, Mike Roser, another triumph”
My Review: Bright notes dance on your palate in this everyday red. We took one home. November 2024
Scott Harvey Wines
We finished our day with a very quick stop at Scott Harvey. The impressive wines are definitely worthy of a revisit and more time to explore the whole collection – with a fresh palate.
About Scott Harvey: I encourage you to click this link and read the whole, beautiful story of Scott Harvey “Where Passion Meets Heritage”
“At the heart of our winemaking journey lies a story of love, heritage, and an unyielding passion for creating exceptional wines. It all began in the picturesque vineyards of Amador County, where Scott, our founder, grew up savoring the rich flavors of his step-grandfather’s homemade wine, crafted from the very grapes that adorned their family estate…With winemaking coursing through his veins, Scott returned to the Sierras, determined to elevate Amador County to a world-class wine region.
“Tirelessly pioneering the area’s potential, he immersed himself in various wineries, honing his craft, until destiny beckoned him to Napa Valley, a mecca for any winemaker. Scott’s winemaking mentor had just bought a small winery in Napa and needed a winemaker for the project. Dr. Richard Peterson asked Scott to make it a takeover candidate by a bigger winery. Scott went to work and created Menage a Trois which did the job. But despite the allure of Napa, his heart remained steadfast in Amador. The turning point arrived when the Napa winery he worked at was sold, presenting Scott with the golden opportunity to reclaim his dream.”
2021 Scott Harvey Vineyard 1869 Zinfandel, Amador County, 14.9% ABV, $75 (#1500)
Winery Notes: “Briary varietal layered Zinfandel, dark color, marjoram spice, bright cherry, tomato, white pepper, medium French oak, luscious center, layered complexity. Old Vine complexity and first growth quality.” “Crafted from the oldest documented Zinfandel vines in the U.S., delivering a piece of history in every sip. ALMOST SOLD OUT!” 90% Zinfandel, 10% Primitivo
My Review: Dark jammy nose. Finished with orange peel. As the last wines of the day, I did not capture thorough tasting notes. We took some home, so I will update this upon a revisit. November 2024
THE TASTING ROOMS
Due to the length of today’s post, please check each winery’s website for details on when and where to taste their wines.
© Decanting Monterey 2025
*FOLLOW ME ON Instagram, Facebook, and CELLAR TRACKER: Central Coast Sharon
Recent Comments